In the current version of the film "3:10 to Yuma," the home base of the rancher played by Christian Bale is Bisbee, Arizona. A lot of screen time is spent in or around Bisbee, shown as a flat and dusty landscape, not unlike many other westerns that feature an "outpost" town. Think of John Ford and
Stagecoach and the landscape in that movie, and that's how Bisbee is depicted in this film.
As much as I love this movie, (my grandfather, Paul Powers, was a pulp Western writer, after all, who wrote for
Wild West Weekly magazine from 1928 to 1943), I have to take issue with the visual depiction of Bisbee. It's not accurate. Anybody who's been to Bisbee knows one thing for sure: it ain't flat. On the contrary: Bisbee is a town perched on hills, nestled amongst the Mule Mountains.

It began as a mining stake in 1880 and eventually became known for having some of the richest deposits of lead, copper, silver, zinc, and yes, gold. It eventually earned the title as the "Queen of the Copper Camps." A devastating fire in 1908 that nearly wiped out the entire commerical district didn't dissuade the townfolk, who quickly rebuilt. By 1910, 25,000 people lived in Bisbee, and in 1929, the county of Chocise changed the county seat from Tombstone to Bisbee. Even though the mining operations shut down in the mid 1970s, Bisbee lives on as a thriving artist's community.
Bisbee was one of the first places I visited when researching my grandfather's life, before
"Pulp Writer" was published. I had no idea where or what Bisbee was about; all I knew was that it was in the far southeast corner of the state, close to the Mexican border. It sounded colorful and slightly off-center, like my grandfather. After being at Smith College in Massachusetts and surviving another winter there, spring in Arizona - late spring nonetheless - sounded blissful and bucolic. So after I flew home to Los Angeles in June of 1999 for summer break, I dropped my suitcases at my friend Barbara's apartment and took off for Bisbee and Tombstone.
Here are my notes from that trip in May, 1999:
It is now one o’clock in the afternoon, and the temperature in my car is well over the one hundred degrees outside. Even with all of my preparation before leaving Los Angeles, somewhere around Tucson, hot air started to blow out of the air conditioning vents. The water jug in the seat next to me, efficiently loaded with ice cubes this morning, is now nothing but hot liquid. I open the windows, push my little car and try to cool myself, but the hot wind whipping through my hair doesn’t help. Six hours into this drive, I realize that I’m only halfway to my destination, Bisbee, on the far southeastern corner of Arizona.
The giant cactus that greeted me when I first passed the state line on the road to Phoenix, bordering the highway like stately emblems of a bygone era, have disappeared. The road slices through relentless dust and rock, interrupted only by stubby brush and short cactus and a occasional dust devil whirling off the ground for a few seconds, then dissipating as quickly as it arrives. Hours pass between exits, and when they arrive, they tempt the driver with a fresh new road that winds off into the horizon like a shiny ribbon.
While doing my research, I envisioned Grandpa and Mary living in Arizona in a desolate weatherbeaten house, in a grim border town, in a flat landscape void of color, like an old black and white Western. Now I steer through small canyons that are turning from yellow gold to rust and orange with the setting sun. I hit the crest of the ridge between Tombstone and Bisbee, and I instantly know why my grandfather had lived here.
Spread out, hundreds of miles wide, is a valley that is the most heart stopping landscape I have ever encountered. It is flanked by mountain ranges on the western and eastern sides. Down in the valley, dark green clusters of trees surround tin roofs that briefly glitter in the sunset. The basin could be thousands of miles or could be ten – the breadth of it and the clear air makes perception totally askew. Grandpa knew exactly what he was doing when he moved here.
I continue up the road. It turns and leads me up into a canyon until the rocky walls sandwich the road so tightly that I flinch as I pass by jutting boulders. The pass winds down again. The sun is starting to set. I worry: will I make it before dark? I drive through a tunnel, turn another corner, and there, gently rising on the hill to the left of me, is Bisbee, sparkling like a Mediterranean villa. Grandpa talks about Bisbee being a "spectacular little city," and that was in 1933. He was right.
The town is safely insulated from the rest of the world, sealed in by high rust-colored hills covered with yucca cactus and sagebrush. I still have a few minutes before darkness settles, so I stand outside and survey the town, which isn’t hard to do. Neighborhoods teeter on both sides of a canyon, a mixture of old shacks with paint peeling and little architectural dignity and homes well preserved and complemented by meticulous gardens. The streets are deserted.

Everyone is at the high school, the woman at the Bisbee Inn explains as she escorts me to my room. This is graduation night. Everything is so close here that I can hear people chatting on a hill across town as they climb the stairs to their home, as if they were next door. A dog barks in the back of a pick-up truck speeding on Main Street below, his bark reverberating between the hills. This would not be a good town to have a talkative pet. Or a loud family, for that matter.
In the morning, I lean against the railing and look at the business district below. Downtown buildings are solid brick, constructed after the first Bisbee was destroyed in a fire. A saloon, a restaurant, a pizza parlor are opening up for the day. I listen to the sounds of doors slamming, pots banging, an occasional curt remark from a worker. There is a coffee house with chairs outside; it will have the best view of the tour buses that will start rolling into town in a few hours, because Bisbee isn’t immune to the gradually increasing trickle of tourism that seeps in from Tombstone.
I walk down the main street; it is still early and the stores are not open. A man, who seems not to have realized that the bars closed hours ago, leers at me with blurred eyes before swinging around and staggering across the street to join another man who also seems to have lost his barstool. I know from reading my grandfather's memoirs that he lurked around these saloons while Mary stayed at home with the three kids. In fact, he admits that he acquired a "sinister reputation" here. Part of that might be because he fratnerized with the Chinese population, many of whom were transported to the area to work in the mines. He even smoked opium with them once, an event that he describes in detail in "
Pulp Writer."
In the late nineteenth century, mining flourished in Bisbee, and so did hangings, gunfight, drunkenness and prostitution. But Bisbee suffered mightily later in the dark years of the Great Depression. Even though it was one of the richest copper districts in the country, it was practially a company town because the main employer, the Phelps Dodge Company, owned the largest hotel in town, the hospital, department store, library, in addition to other businesses. After the stock market crashed and banks closed, mining also took a dive. The local economy foundered, pushing the town to its limits. Businesses faltered and workers languished, waiting for work that never came. Eventually townspeople moved away, abandoning their little homes on the hills, never to return.
I walk down the narrow Main Street to the Chamber of Commerce. Where can I get information on the town during the 1930s? The woman there directs me to the library and the town museum. We start to chat about the town. By World War II, the town had recovered, and the area continued to prosper after the county seat was moved to Bisbee. Lucky new residents snatched up the empty houses that previous owners had abandoned. Now, many people from Tucson come down to Bisbee to escape the summer heat of their part of the desert. The new power group in Bisbee, however, is a citizenry of artists and musicians who fiercely ward off any threats of commercialism that may sneak into the city. The town is doing fairly well now, she says. There are a lot of retirees and vacationers. “But there is still an element here,” she says slowly. An element. Was my grandfather was considered an “element” when he was here?
My last morning in Bisbee, I look down at an entire town that has been frozen in 1880. The residents have done a good job of refusing to succumb to franchise frenzy. The books that are sold in town discuss the old mining days. The locally owned businesses are thriving. I haven’t been able to find out much about Bisbee during the Depression, however, because most of the information immediately available to visitors discusses the town’s mining days prior to the turn of the century. Anything that happened after the nineteenth century apparently isn’t of much interest to tourists. I’ve visited in the wrong time era; I’ll have to wait until the 1930s come into vogue. As long as the legend of the Wild West captivates people's imagination, these towns will pay homage to that era one way or another, either in capitalism as in Tombstone, or in preservation as in Bisbee. I give up, get in my car and head towards Tombstone.
Next....returning to Bisbee in 2007.... Tombstone......Tucscon.....